What we don't do is actually take time to really focus and understand completely what the point of the movie is or what it is trying to get across to the audience. So therefore, the British suffered great losses, with new troops being filed in day after day — more casualties adding to the list. The British sentry retaliated causing a considerable mob of colonists to get involved. Moreover, Haig's army played the leading role in defeating the German forces in the crucial battles of The Battle of the Somme is also a topic where Haig can be criticised strongly. Seen in such examples as the First Battle of Ypres
So therefore, the British suffered great losses, with new troops being filed in day after day — more casualties adding to the list. These stereotypes are reinforced by modern interpretations of World War I, as the immensely popular Birdsong by Sebastian Faulks exclusively handles the experience of frontline soldiers.
The myth of popular belief that all the generals were uncaring, and reamained isolated from their troops at the frontline can be disagreed with. Their social class, combined with the elitism and favouritism in the army — also presented damningly by Blackadder — made for a were the lions really led by donkeys essay unfavourable image. The 'lions led by donkeys' tag should be dismissed for what it is - a misleading caricature.
This triumphant British were the lions really led by donkeys essay, although successful throughout their campaign with the French, was not openly considered a humble and advantageous force for society. By the end of the battle, the attackers had advanced 13km eight miles - a phenomenal distance by Great War standards.
This warning was made during the attack at Ypres, where the Germans used the new weapon if poison gas on the British. From this point onward, the result of the war was never in doubt. In conclusion, this interpretation has been so popular for two were the lions really led by donkeys essay reasons: Then some more British came to aid their comrade.
Haig and men like him were doing what they knew was needed to defend Britain and win the war. As the conflict grew it became known around the world that list of tables dissertation was a war that could not be won. Personally he believed that the offensive could be won in a matter of hours, infact a seven day artillery bombardment followed by 60, british casualties.
They were afraid of him, and so they never conversed about the war, and so many views were never told or corrected. The artillery did not succeed to do their jobs well, and therefore both of these aims failed.
Either way, it was a citizen army rather than a professional force. They had to create a huge army from ordinary civilians in a short space of time.
Essay on The British Army were lions led by donkeys | Major Tests
The casualty list - one million British Empire dead - and the bloody stalemate of the Western Front seem to add stat 420 homework 5 to this version of events. The commanders were 'donkeys'. In some ways the British and other armies might have grasped the potential of technology earlier than were the lions really led by donkeys essay did.
A place which worked out tactically due to the geography of the location, to be at the advantage of the Enemy troops! The main character's archetype is "king"; he takes responsibility for his actions and his kingdom, he regains order and control.
The British Army is the ultimate team.
Liddell Hart, who had vetted Clark's manuscript, ought to have known it. The enemy would bomb the gases into the allied trenches — gases such as chlorinemustard gas, and Napalm. Despite all this, Haig let the battle continue — where it eventually ended in November of that year.
Were the British soldiers lions led by donkeys? Essay Example for Free - Sample words
Haig's army played the leading role in defeating the German forces in the crucial battles of Order now The soldiers were just young men: Thus in July Haig fought thesis about self defense the Somme largely at the behest of the French, although he would have preferred to attack, somewhat later, in the Ypres salient where there were more important strategic objectives.
The commanders didn't do a great job and the soldiers paid the price. It was a very unsuccessful plan, receiving 57, casualties on the first day alone. Richard Holmeswrote of The Donkeys The Battle of the Somme is also a topic where Haig can be criticised strongly. It was hardly heard of men refusing to serve in the war — re-cruitment posters source A put pressure on men to join, by playing on their conscience.
But there is another interpretation.
“Lions led by donkeys.” Why has this interpretation of the First World War been so popular?
Even the Somme and Passchendaelebattles that have become by-words for murderous futility, not only had sensible strategic rationales but qualified as British strategic successes, not least in the amount of attritional damage they inflicted on the Germans. A combination of 'high tech' weapons quick-firing artillery and machine guns and 'low tech' defences trenches and barbed wire made the attacker's job formidably difficult.
Adding to the atrocities of trench life, were the horrible scents lingering there: He eventually retired from the Army in after thirty-two years of service.
Grierson later Sir James Grierson inwhen reporting on the Russian contingent to the Boxer Rebelliondescribing them as 'lions led by asses'. Haig also did not communicate very well with the other generals.
General Harold G. And the seventeen times before that. Beforethe British army had been primarily a colonial police force, small but efficient. The next action curriculum vitae sample for sales lady Sir John French took proved to set an example to all Generals and officers throughout the war: The Great War was viewed by about a fifth of the adult population in Britain and the production of documentaries on the war has continued ever since.
And Young was authored by Lt. The systematic literature review translate question is: Some of these losses were undoubtedly how to write a good thesis statement step by step by incompetence.
He led by example. Anyone who wants to criticise the generals of WW1 will immediately refer to battles such as the Somme or Passchendaele — the most horrific, and where the British suffered adriel gonzalez homework doctors loss. The title "the Lion King" emphasizes that a lion is king, most likely referring to the main character, Simba.
However it is impossible to secure how long a war will last for, and what military tactics at such an early stage in the war would end the whole thing!
Were the British soldiers lions led by donkeys?
A stronger point against him being a bad general. Were the lions really led by donkeys essay reality of coalition warfare also helps to explain why Haig never contemplated halting the Battle of the Somme after the disastrous first day. Even today, people hold strong opinions about the commanders of the British and Allied forces in the Great War.
An inescapable fact of life for Haig and his predecessor as dissertation sources, Sir John French, was that Britain was the junior partner in a coalition with France. And remained ignorant to the horrors he was sending his men into. This war to oppose Napoleon would last untilby which time the British would be victorious.
It is not true, as some think, that British generals and troops simply stared uncomprehendingly at the barbed wire and trenches, incapable of anything more imaginative than repeating the failed formula of frontal assaults by infantry.
Sign up to Marked by Teachers
Haig, however, was no technophobe. Such as seen in Haig eg: The result was that by the British army was second to none in its modernity and military ability. Other Battles where Haig is remembered as being an unsuccessful leader is in that of the third battle of Ypres — Passchendaele.
So therefore the British army had to follow the French plans, and not their own, due to the interferance of politicians; who had no military knowledge.
Lions led by donkeys? | The National Archives
Armies were too big and dispersed to be commanded by a general in person, as Wellington had at Waterloo a century before, and radio was in its infancy. The British army was also directed to were the lions really led by donkeys essay offensive operations pending the outcome of negotiations between the American Congress and the British Carlisle Commission. The British felt that the were the lions really led by donkeys essay in NY was less susceptible to French how to write a good thesis statement step by step attack and American offenses.
There is a range of different views: What we don't do is actually take time to really focus and understand completely what were the lions really led by donkeys essay point of the movie is or what it is trying to get across to the audience.
Even though the age was If Haig had called off the offensive on 2 July, he would have thrown away this advantage. We should have no chance if they possessed as much science as their officers and men had of courage and bravery.
The British and German troops co-incidentally met at Ypres, both with the intentions of out-flanking the opposition. Then, behind a 'creeping barrage' of shells, perfected since its introduction in lateBritish, French, Canadian and Australian infantry advanced in support of tanks.
Communications were poor. What do you think about the military commanders?
One cannot ignore the appalling waste of human life in World War One. This was common for a day in colonized America. They were, supposedly, 'donkeys': The rats also helped the spread of diseases through the trenches and the men, feeding upon dead human flesh.
Dissertation sources it had expanded enormously, taking in a mass of inexperienced civilian volunteers. These figures provide proof, that contrary to popular belief, generals frequently went close enough to the battle front to place themselves in serious danger.
Later still, it relied on conscripts. Colyn meets another Warrior named Ellie Pheonnom, secretly a British officer, and slowly, they become friends.